When considering high-performance polymers, two materials that are brought into discussion the most are Ethylene Tetrafluoroethylene (ETFE) and Polyvinylidene Fluoride (PVDF).

While both are members of the fluoropolymer family, differences in their characteristics make them fit for different uses.

This blog post is all about discussing the major dissimilation between ETFE and PVDF concerning their chemical structure, properties, and real-life applications.

ETFE vs PVDF - Key Properties and Characteristics

Chemical Structure: The Foundation of Difference

At the molecular level, ETFE and PVDF share similarities but have crucial differences:

• PVDF: Its molecular structure alternates between -CH2- and -CF2- groups, resulting in a basic polymer unit of -CH2-CF2-.
• ETFE: This polymer alternates between -CH2-CH2- and -CF2-CF2- groups, creating a basic unit of -CH2-CH2-CF2-CF2-.

The slight difference in arrangement affects their properties so greatly that they differ in performance as well.

Physical Properties: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Appearance

Both ETFE and PVDF are usually available as translucent particles or white powders and hence bear some resemblance to one another in appearance.

Melting Point

• PVDF: 150°C to 185°C
• ETFE: 260°C to 280°C (up to 310°C for highly alternating varieties)

ETFE has a higher melting point due to its molecular structure, which is more rigid, and thus more highly crystalline.

Thermal Stability

• PVDF: Begins to decompose at temperatures above 300°C
• ETFE: Starts decomposing at temperatures exceeding 340°C

While both materials are heat-resistant, ETFE has a slight edge in thermal stability.

Operating Temperature Range

• PVDF: -40°C to 150°C
• ETFE: -70°C to 150°C

ETFE offers a broader range of usable temperatures, particularly at the lower end of the spectrum.

Flame Retardancy

• PVDF: Limiting Oxygen Index (LOI) of 44
• ETFE: LOI of 30-31

Both materials are non-combustible in air, but PVDF demonstrates superior flame-retardant properties.

Performance Characteristics: Where They Excel

Mechanical Properties

ETFE is the strongest of all fluoropolymers, which have very good mechanical toughness and outstanding tensile strength, reaching as high as 46 MPa at room temperature. It has high elongation at break, reaching as high as up to 300%. Its creep resistance is superior compared to other fluoropolymers like PTFE and FEP.

Though still not as good as ETFE, PVDF has quite good mechanical strength properties anyway in different kinds of applications. It has high tensile strength with excellent impact resistance and outstanding wear-resistance properties. Talking about creep resistance, PVDF is one of the best in the fluoropolymer family.

Electrical Properties

ETFE is a dielectric material with a low and frequency-stable dielectric constant, of 2.5 to 2.6. Its dielectric constant, even at high frequencies like 10 GHz, remains close to 2.3, where the dielectric loss is at a minimum.

On the other hand, PVDF has a higher value of dielectric constant: its dielectric constant runs in the range of 6-8, with more dielectric loss. However, it possesses unique piezoelectric and thermoelectric properties, making it valuable for specific applications.

Chemical Resistance

Both ETFE and PVDF exhibit excellent chemical resistance, but their solubility differs:

• PVDF can dissolve in polar organic solvents like acetone and tetrahydrofuran at room temperature.
• ETFE is more resistant to solvents, dissolving only in select substances at elevated temperatures.

Manufacturing Methods: From Monomers to Polymers

The synthesis of ETFE and PVDF involves different approaches:

PVDF Production

• Primary monomer: Vinylidene fluoride (VDF)
• Additional monomers for modification: Hexafluoropropylene (HFP), Chlorotrifluoroethylene (CTFE), Tetrafluoroethylene (TFE)
• Polymerization methods: Emulsion and suspension polymerization

ETFE Production

• Primary monomers: Tetrafluoroethylene (TFE) and ethylene
• Modifying monomers: Various perfluorinated vinyl ethers and ethylenes
• Polymerization method: Typically involves free-radical polymerization

Real-World Applications: Where ETFE and PVDF Shine

The unique properties of these materials lead to diverse applications across industries:

ETFE Applications

• Architecture: ETFE films are becoming increasingly used in modern building design due to their higher light transmittance compared with glass, good deformation ability, and outstanding impact resistance.
• Wire and Cable Insulation: Very high-performance cables utilize crosslinked ETFE ETFE (X-ETFE) insulation, offering excellent electrical properties with lower weight.
• Aerospace: ETFE is useful in aerospace applications due to its lightweight and thermal stability.

PVDF Applications

• Lithium-Ion Batteries: PVDF is the go-to material for cathode binders in Li-ion batteries, accounting for about 90% of the market due to its chemical stability and bonding properties.
• Coatings: PVDF-based coatings offer exceptional durability, resisting oxidation, UV degradation, and various environmental factors. They're widely used in architectural applications for exterior walls and roofs.
• Membranes: The chemical resistance of PVDF makes it ideal for filtration membranes in water treatment and chemical processing.

Final Thoughts: Choice Between ETFE and PVDF

Even though ETFE and, to some extent, PVDF share some similarities, the differences established make each material best suited for a specific application.

ETFE has higher strength, a wider temperature range, and excellent electrical properties that make it a go-to material for architectural and high-performance wire applications.

Excellent chemical resistance combined with particular electrical characteristics makes PVDF especially suitable for energy storage and protective coatings.

Understanding the differences between these (ETFE and PVDF) materials can help engineers, designers, and industry professionals make appropriate choices according to their needs.

For high-quality ETFE, PVDF, and other fluoropolymers, trust Advecton to deliver. Our specialists are at your service to help you pick the perfect material for your requirements.

Let Advecton help drive innovation within your industry. We are going to be your fluoropolymer solution collaborator for years to come.

---

Explore Our Industrial Fluoropolymers

• ETFE (Ethylene Tetrafluoroethylene)
• PVDF (Polyvinylidene Fluoride)